Convergence issues with Ibrion=1 and vasp5.2.12 for multiple systems
Posted: Wed Oct 10, 2012 4:15 am
Hello,
I have been a VASP user for a while but have now started noticing issues with VASP convergence recently for multiple systems.
Specifically, for my system I carry out geometry optimization with the CG method (with or without spin, POTIM = 0.1) and end up with the ZBRENT warning (curvature = 0). Since, I can't find an optimum POTIM value for the ZBRENT ionic step, I 'choose' a reasonable POTIM and shift to Quasi Newton and keep a track of the maximum force on the atoms and the maximum displacement.
--
Ionic Steps
Step 1: max disp= 38.30604158 f= 0.13431398 for atom O (104)
Step 2: max disp= 0.00129534 f= 0.13439252 for atom O (104)
Step 3: max disp= 0.00003000 f= 0.09108829 for atom O (151)
Step 4: max disp= 0.00107634 f= 0.09241037 for atom O (104)
Step 5: max disp= 0.00049285 f= 0.13178783 for atom O (104)
Step 6: max disp= 0.00088798 f= 0.11513393 for atom O (104)
Step 7: max disp= 0.00092136 f= 0.12207442 for atom O (104)
Step 8: max disp= 0.00139334 f= 0.12624884 for atom O (104)
Step 9: max disp= 0.00200125 f= 0.17448056 for atom O (151)
--
In each case the ionic displacements are small (one hundredth of an angstrom) but the forces seem to oscillate or diverge. I cannot seem to get them to be lower thatn 0.03 eV/ang.
I have tried the following
1. Try CG with potim= 0.1, 0.01, 0.001 to try and find 'optimum'. It always give the ZBRENT error.
2. Try QN with potim = 0.1, 0.05 .... Even though I am so close to the minimum the force does not decrease
3. Increase the SCF accuracy by changing EDIFF and the minimum number of SCF cycles
4. Change NFREE = 0, 1, 5 10 .. none of them work
5. I can't change ENCUT = 400 as I am comparing different structures at the same encut value
6. Check the compiler version (intel 11.1.059 and 12.0.0.089) and vasp version (12 and 13).
7. I am still having convergence issue both with spin on and spin off.
If I am close to the minima (as the curvature is zero), shouldn't the QN method converge immediately? This is happening for multiple systems and I can't figure out what the issue could be. I have been trying for more than a couple of months without any success.
I'd really appreciate some feedback.
Thank you,
Regards,
Ambarish
POTCAR
----
TITEL = PAW_PBE H 15Jun2001
TITEL = PAW_PBE C 08Apr2002
TITEL = PAW_PBE N 08Apr2002
TITEL = PAW_PBE O 08Apr2002
TITEL = PAW_PBE Cu 05Jan2001
INCAR
----
SYSTEM=Charge_calculation
# Files to read and write
LCHARG= .TRUE.
LWAVE = .TRUE.
LAECHG= .FALSE.
LVTOT = .FALSE.
# spin polarized
ISPIN=2
ICHARG=1
MAGMOM = 16*0 72*0 8*0 64*0 6*1 6*-1 #16 72 8 64 12
LORBIT = 11
# Electronic steps
PREC = Accurate
ENCUT = 400.000
ENAUG =650.000
NELMDL= -4
NELMIN= 4
EDIFF = 1E-04
ALGO = Fast
NSIM = 4
LREAL = Auto
# Ionic steps
NSW = 1000
IBRION= 1
ADDGRID = .TRUE.
#NFREE = 10
EDIFFG= -3E-02
ISIF = 2
POTIM = 0.1
ISMEAR= 0
NPAR = 4
LPLANE= .TRUE.
# Grimmes method
LVDW = .TRUE.
VDW_RADIUS = 30.0
VDW_SCALING = 0.75 s6 value for PBE
VDW_D = 20.0 parameter d in the dampling function
---
POSCAR
---
test
0.990000000000000
18.7136999999999993 0.0000000000000000 0.0000000000000000
9.3568499999999997 16.2065395999999993 0.0000000000000000
9.3568499999999997 5.4021799000000001 15.2796721000000009
H C N O Cu
16 72 8 64 12
Selective dynamics
Direct
0.0314546404051822 0.7328471105721247 0.5014210140064779 T T T
0.0297079775603472 0.5017603893969818 0.7347034973128451 T T T
0.2667527858351689 0.4961938025785905 0.2638207152459398 T T T
0.2674088685279770 0.2644375198557865 0.4964735844306852 T T T
0.7322329007340624 0.5041262269399471 0.0268993629906784 T T T
0.7318979230394315 0.7356378115211368 0.0286195767091692 T T T
0.5022229941855245 0.0286606096771823 0.7357693887204564 T T T
0.7349372714090950 0.0268293258726596 0.5038754407313335 T T T
0.2655199095730504 0.9732324930681678 0.2651977114929445 T T T
0.4977794428439334 0.9720969757581450 0.2664512953404236 T T T
0.2625215332374135 0.4974785512533964 0.9720280624581271 T T T
0.4955602663596327 0.2661217051180355 0.9706865047450199 T T T
0.9686618267112393 0.4976792549760107 0.2667913260820983 T T T
0.9710395179639552 0.2639822071878066 0.4975844943321546 T T T
0.5025170034831945 0.7336955721574689 0.7321543529298061 T T T
0.7352561252204430 0.5020960062383529 0.7319764177380066 T T T
0.0266930254135202 0.5676871455943954 0.5683119618795689 T T T
0.0323120242999455 0.6119503030115542 0.6125776503590579 T T T
0.0326439676895392 0.6985013381652361 0.5688717791324317 T T T
0.0315010070187796 0.5690039387810518 0.6996143806917675 T T T
0.0319648049435121 0.7430330203947391 0.6116970093542794 T T T
0.0305395673599559 0.6123304751360424 0.7438123156363912 T T T
0.0266795880782160 0.8371179168446513 0.5637443402379853 T T T
0.0233474548165889 0.5653932287939553 0.8384923374029011 T T T
0.0308698527415197 0.6996309579405573 0.6993875596877110 T T T
0.1642137569207709 0.4302449084836067 0.4293299644893470 T T T
0.2582987959693865 0.3858549693511201 0.3855515148089448 T T T
0.3013021475659238 0.4292103473934300 0.2987235135240902 T T T
0.3016489324218647 0.2993595095281715 0.4292805645667302 T T T
0.3882518039525445 0.3867659487425664 0.2546420413991544 T T T
0.3888222598647282 0.2556643401389718 0.3867360491552819 T T T
0.4283387358133155 0.4341873254417804 0.1599305511845300 T T T
0.4303620681589307 0.1616477288683499 0.4344844028668105 T T T
0.4320904537806973 0.2999375609174625 0.2993766248404284 T T T
0.5704424587150616 0.5663446581423447 0.0226689148414055 T T T
0.6107000249276175 0.6135291098387239 0.0300292388433967 T T T
0.5669046422873255 0.7003281938903977 0.0319144657440145 T T T
0.6977285234698456 0.5710961793630637 0.0294387553999455 T T T
0.6102322222436578 0.7445457116402555 0.0317026817790197 T T T
0.5687411228864871 0.8385637774676993 0.0269130632376131 T T T
0.6974560775899811 0.7008231229686606 0.0307299760947297 T T T
0.7407725152571834 0.6144350744311355 0.0299829586781568 T T T
0.8349590514158605 0.5701766233657143 0.0238469615110206 T T T
0.5690691261216742 0.0232706014607518 0.5707034817022043 T T T
0.6132455197534110 0.0294218327746241 0.6145676249227153 T T T
0.5696957890155152 0.0298197346438362 0.7011400498102468 T T T
0.6128487952254718 0.0290289022729068 0.7454145799250146 T T T
0.7001752251260775 0.0288475860019731 0.5710557719501045 T T T
0.5654550314646565 0.0232782556492474 0.8397593727121317 T T T
0.7444476294236664 0.0285370093089614 0.6138265838712237 T T T
0.7003450676522520 0.0286669956211352 0.7012457070357556 T T T
0.8388989373247273 0.0221618931560139 0.5663691331969118 T T T
0.1622163842522782 0.9756531876827486 0.4278442276399677 T T T
0.2565563154124961 0.9695251091853125 0.3870602761827414 T T T
0.3004097972643590 0.9705874608622913 0.2999124717651044 T T T
0.4311467058464787 0.9773807861466337 0.1626328814962017 T T T
0.3006450881062386 0.9689408132411280 0.4308274183784889 T T T
0.3870993663713686 0.9707381401130746 0.2569769444590434 T T T
0.4305662530439303 0.9701955208053852 0.3005857779106677 T T T
0.3877036764432140 0.9697837475621301 0.3876664828293550 T T T
0.4347570757641749 0.9757580706924323 0.4290711234682729 T T T
0.1589013926990945 0.4347229361570106 0.9768472314185984 T T T
0.2536288207471321 0.3875914091208595 0.9696943037652010 T T T
0.2985207535859735 0.3006871832268335 0.9681204228539392 T T T
0.2975939476973446 0.4304088786843907 0.9697706607768244 T T T
0.4333683641839866 0.1622713896243650 0.9745585115813518 T T T
0.3857431969541562 0.2565905876086940 0.9686145566139374 T T T
0.4283176299030663 0.3007208859902952 0.9688735183172613 T T T
0.3846170727130697 0.3873597969859182 0.9689172905136517 T T T
0.4288064302343300 0.4320504471537673 0.9738699030230715 T T T
0.9687541883684809 0.3000154130046259 0.2999634094134248 T T T
0.9716252690221433 0.4363270831798626 0.1628616809055520 T T T
0.9747944915781781 0.1610963236738497 0.4345761784937485 T T T
0.9675359679808226 0.3877764168596466 0.2566129089061943 T T T
0.9689345875239441 0.2554923894780764 0.3873273066072590 T T T
0.9677026700356592 0.4301571506368507 0.3010018073815382 T T T
0.9689731850178710 0.2992600687017351 0.4304308959964563 T T T
0.9690214596627157 0.3860361357558801 0.3872087730337914 T T T
0.9763574187244417 0.4297572032073753 0.4307600270791518 T T T
0.5699797385950707 0.6992134188601870 0.6979759687597690 T T T
0.5692399296917015 0.5680155398389437 0.8349010857023158 T T T
0.5660407508877472 0.8382109542751981 0.5710977974284699 T T T
0.6134637436811465 0.6124516680413126 0.7408943896197402 T T T
0.6132526595459008 0.7437806624018281 0.6116290033840182 T T T
0.7007964769662830 0.7000662719597421 0.5683934251286075 T T T
0.7004972157037964 0.5693969295398345 0.6978118887645884 T T T
0.7450234759971872 0.6126097599875676 0.6113565842041800 T T T
0.8395911862256692 0.5653958751250332 0.5706350741170336 T T T
0.0276600726137025 0.7472208554582975 0.7463380916687482 T T T
0.5247406330190387 0.2540058885325480 0.2532943358968928 T T T
0.4741669657729822 0.7462150468837000 0.0327589194569062 T T T
0.7471027976625557 0.0261334549793207 0.7485963874966202 T T T
0.2545505424215165 0.9680212062263306 0.5236102284785358 T T T
0.9721979962926756 0.2531433683004055 0.2521540439623274 T T T
0.7480109715761756 0.7478479882981637 0.4773149800128820 T T T
0.2531824722757034 0.2545345329517040 0.9667240877101591 T T T
0.0264119074522771 0.6117108632556785 0.4889716125283541 T T T
0.0202977698980699 0.4906968064274217 0.6150258600898931 T T T
0.0132377595699680 0.8726786082021999 0.4902934023603134 T T T
0.0251718440403447 0.4857488732272404 0.8709370126676179 T T T
0.0340844297515667 0.8735580605922225 0.6013506914448769 T T T
0.0135262823848723 0.6105066505118817 0.8786759555231586 T T T
0.9536013054901714 0.7917240910869022 0.7829252589590054 T T T
0.0993932167855757 0.7375570524067203 0.7443382769692786 T T T
0.1280961179348254 0.3856043922356401 0.5078906663530185 T T T
0.1283314346772920 0.5080505270490205 0.3829711374037283 T T T
0.3807438284572169 0.5119969242147773 0.1264269285319793 T T T
0.3795955722046745 0.1243726294049130 0.5070215836303367 T T T
0.5059494544228960 0.3909693123889380 0.1208511479647651 T T T
0.5124290935130800 0.1268957679410119 0.3970792942110131 T T T
0.5822818902608078 0.2655888324152492 0.2575681651429148 T T T
0.5355919582145668 0.2088844464497902 0.2151061044502367 T T T
0.4927673835800621 0.6096265895009644 0.0180971207267199 T T T
0.6179454323542188 0.4886071683177725 0.0191043781244153 T T T
0.4867118255791860 0.8735051071667725 0.0365269021401143 T T T
0.6195453856101558 0.8756493779133490 0.0116356652328914 T T T
0.8725419133995033 0.4962068138406518 0.0107526799757304 T T T
0.8693508098641677 0.6108273292516090 0.0300961666054597 T T T
0.4167405284816941 0.7345232993835062 0.1062763316417818 T T T
0.4630373099092234 0.7912938284028104 0.9604399692308236 T T T
0.4871338168783322 0.0318421978793000 0.6110420959611774 T T T
0.6183223279735872 0.0075388891956658 0.4979795409028779 T T T
0.4938300871568695 0.0060580027887788 0.8771061178536824 T T T
0.6017160607539214 0.0343865847722593 0.8747473431803767 T T T
0.8712449453363360 0.0259698541777330 0.4861460000670701 T T T
0.8789342235268216 0.0110165484979829 0.6124032144965708 T T T
0.7825236917344318 0.9525565233031974 0.7945688421781760 T T T
0.7456500399245993 0.0981512043020172 0.7377004997134674 T T T
0.1308557435233137 0.9667154363468673 0.3865145917400608 T T T
0.1212167896552429 0.9922864845876184 0.5000519424299149 T T T
0.3819126514225625 0.9932443205478224 0.1233539408445861 T T T
0.5130774075933016 0.9687357166323131 0.1297385484927316 T T T
0.3984446294888719 0.9645959917236533 0.5114464523737411 T T T
0.5061324561139913 0.9934867509156174 0.3775721816459950 T T T
0.1190512369078054 0.3897535403692099 0.9858214289369904 T T T
0.1261591239953944 0.5140862974391538 0.9759048806354182 T T T
0.3976144140723614 0.1271965660840621 0.9629268608473056 T T T
0.5043249313754875 0.1250524274324135 0.9928992387774517 T T T
0.3815907350534134 0.5089570545411101 0.9804882531914327 T T T
0.5084264533052523 0.3887030285280743 0.9731692722385120 T T T
0.9644683900898213 0.3985541591709347 0.1264207950223285 T T T
0.9882522192160714 0.1202548641245594 0.3881816769975774 T T T
0.9838367529206068 0.5104304975431357 0.1274188408973625 T T T
0.9683612981052371 0.1295552445455221 0.5156112514281124 T T T
0.9808341733394270 0.5075851405290215 0.3850093018322613 T T T
0.9799021079833354 0.3841309459782932 0.5088339152011248 T T T
0.4898404459989499 0.6116378103380076 0.8705419368101214 T T T
0.4948689069170510 0.8752915549578417 0.6230577843428566 T T T
0.6164968699576272 0.4911824464104594 0.8712672644245005 T T T
0.6024099944300378 0.8732503929543490 0.4887851756622008 T T T
0.8788575245027097 0.6088756059448722 0.4932515361078514 T T T
0.8727765416262988 0.4870307767296108 0.6175803831888662 T T T
0.0463018513887616 0.2173804945261090 0.2070360158397929 T T T
0.7850730030460199 0.7916357666033514 0.4709015279019327 T T T
0.2570574679807853 0.2677203717050666 0.8928321432827793 T T T
0.2572358995217792 0.8945375650496826 0.5807575538440394 T T T
0.2182840750993724 0.0399990421014366 0.5351114891643741 T T T
0.7458564205849308 0.7393340173250682 0.4166662082289213 T T T
0.2164550584695072 0.2076891687241083 0.0384636913044805 T T T
0.9006380347001319 0.2544653370327630 0.2620740212010935 T T T
0.4314368363956531 0.9997889009357193 0.5707614839429125 T T T
0.4296773359767223 0.5681566383150276 0.9980771348826756 T T T
0.0032782707338975 0.5661380330263268 0.4308188163047912 T T T
0.4314141680114737 0.0003541614762466 0.0004877694303379 T T T
0.0008759054007812 0.9972975252663382 0.4293990655374074 T T T
0.9958610034229408 0.4343176637857518 0.9993795752510620 T T T
0.5682028715408406 0.0000889960317890 0.4325640171039207 T T T
0.5687441899690014 0.4325016689756594 0.9963010249533223 T T T
0.0009103163049948 0.4299707219072807 0.5687054732325382 T T T
0.5681524635029344 0.0004361116244331 0.0018732431360659 T T T
0.0003017602909264 0.0008320452448580 0.5657829623101353 T T T
0.9974066110771946 0.5697036247663809 0.0024294224745891 T T T
[ Edited ]
I have been a VASP user for a while but have now started noticing issues with VASP convergence recently for multiple systems.
Specifically, for my system I carry out geometry optimization with the CG method (with or without spin, POTIM = 0.1) and end up with the ZBRENT warning (curvature = 0). Since, I can't find an optimum POTIM value for the ZBRENT ionic step, I 'choose' a reasonable POTIM and shift to Quasi Newton and keep a track of the maximum force on the atoms and the maximum displacement.
--
Ionic Steps
Step 1: max disp= 38.30604158 f= 0.13431398 for atom O (104)
Step 2: max disp= 0.00129534 f= 0.13439252 for atom O (104)
Step 3: max disp= 0.00003000 f= 0.09108829 for atom O (151)
Step 4: max disp= 0.00107634 f= 0.09241037 for atom O (104)
Step 5: max disp= 0.00049285 f= 0.13178783 for atom O (104)
Step 6: max disp= 0.00088798 f= 0.11513393 for atom O (104)
Step 7: max disp= 0.00092136 f= 0.12207442 for atom O (104)
Step 8: max disp= 0.00139334 f= 0.12624884 for atom O (104)
Step 9: max disp= 0.00200125 f= 0.17448056 for atom O (151)
--
In each case the ionic displacements are small (one hundredth of an angstrom) but the forces seem to oscillate or diverge. I cannot seem to get them to be lower thatn 0.03 eV/ang.
I have tried the following
1. Try CG with potim= 0.1, 0.01, 0.001 to try and find 'optimum'. It always give the ZBRENT error.
2. Try QN with potim = 0.1, 0.05 .... Even though I am so close to the minimum the force does not decrease
3. Increase the SCF accuracy by changing EDIFF and the minimum number of SCF cycles
4. Change NFREE = 0, 1, 5 10 .. none of them work
5. I can't change ENCUT = 400 as I am comparing different structures at the same encut value
6. Check the compiler version (intel 11.1.059 and 12.0.0.089) and vasp version (12 and 13).
7. I am still having convergence issue both with spin on and spin off.
If I am close to the minima (as the curvature is zero), shouldn't the QN method converge immediately? This is happening for multiple systems and I can't figure out what the issue could be. I have been trying for more than a couple of months without any success.
I'd really appreciate some feedback.
Thank you,
Regards,
Ambarish
POTCAR
----
TITEL = PAW_PBE H 15Jun2001
TITEL = PAW_PBE C 08Apr2002
TITEL = PAW_PBE N 08Apr2002
TITEL = PAW_PBE O 08Apr2002
TITEL = PAW_PBE Cu 05Jan2001
INCAR
----
SYSTEM=Charge_calculation
# Files to read and write
LCHARG= .TRUE.
LWAVE = .TRUE.
LAECHG= .FALSE.
LVTOT = .FALSE.
# spin polarized
ISPIN=2
ICHARG=1
MAGMOM = 16*0 72*0 8*0 64*0 6*1 6*-1 #16 72 8 64 12
LORBIT = 11
# Electronic steps
PREC = Accurate
ENCUT = 400.000
ENAUG =650.000
NELMDL= -4
NELMIN= 4
EDIFF = 1E-04
ALGO = Fast
NSIM = 4
LREAL = Auto
# Ionic steps
NSW = 1000
IBRION= 1
ADDGRID = .TRUE.
#NFREE = 10
EDIFFG= -3E-02
ISIF = 2
POTIM = 0.1
ISMEAR= 0
NPAR = 4
LPLANE= .TRUE.
# Grimmes method
LVDW = .TRUE.
VDW_RADIUS = 30.0
VDW_SCALING = 0.75 s6 value for PBE
VDW_D = 20.0 parameter d in the dampling function
---
POSCAR
---
test
0.990000000000000
18.7136999999999993 0.0000000000000000 0.0000000000000000
9.3568499999999997 16.2065395999999993 0.0000000000000000
9.3568499999999997 5.4021799000000001 15.2796721000000009
H C N O Cu
16 72 8 64 12
Selective dynamics
Direct
0.0314546404051822 0.7328471105721247 0.5014210140064779 T T T
0.0297079775603472 0.5017603893969818 0.7347034973128451 T T T
0.2667527858351689 0.4961938025785905 0.2638207152459398 T T T
0.2674088685279770 0.2644375198557865 0.4964735844306852 T T T
0.7322329007340624 0.5041262269399471 0.0268993629906784 T T T
0.7318979230394315 0.7356378115211368 0.0286195767091692 T T T
0.5022229941855245 0.0286606096771823 0.7357693887204564 T T T
0.7349372714090950 0.0268293258726596 0.5038754407313335 T T T
0.2655199095730504 0.9732324930681678 0.2651977114929445 T T T
0.4977794428439334 0.9720969757581450 0.2664512953404236 T T T
0.2625215332374135 0.4974785512533964 0.9720280624581271 T T T
0.4955602663596327 0.2661217051180355 0.9706865047450199 T T T
0.9686618267112393 0.4976792549760107 0.2667913260820983 T T T
0.9710395179639552 0.2639822071878066 0.4975844943321546 T T T
0.5025170034831945 0.7336955721574689 0.7321543529298061 T T T
0.7352561252204430 0.5020960062383529 0.7319764177380066 T T T
0.0266930254135202 0.5676871455943954 0.5683119618795689 T T T
0.0323120242999455 0.6119503030115542 0.6125776503590579 T T T
0.0326439676895392 0.6985013381652361 0.5688717791324317 T T T
0.0315010070187796 0.5690039387810518 0.6996143806917675 T T T
0.0319648049435121 0.7430330203947391 0.6116970093542794 T T T
0.0305395673599559 0.6123304751360424 0.7438123156363912 T T T
0.0266795880782160 0.8371179168446513 0.5637443402379853 T T T
0.0233474548165889 0.5653932287939553 0.8384923374029011 T T T
0.0308698527415197 0.6996309579405573 0.6993875596877110 T T T
0.1642137569207709 0.4302449084836067 0.4293299644893470 T T T
0.2582987959693865 0.3858549693511201 0.3855515148089448 T T T
0.3013021475659238 0.4292103473934300 0.2987235135240902 T T T
0.3016489324218647 0.2993595095281715 0.4292805645667302 T T T
0.3882518039525445 0.3867659487425664 0.2546420413991544 T T T
0.3888222598647282 0.2556643401389718 0.3867360491552819 T T T
0.4283387358133155 0.4341873254417804 0.1599305511845300 T T T
0.4303620681589307 0.1616477288683499 0.4344844028668105 T T T
0.4320904537806973 0.2999375609174625 0.2993766248404284 T T T
0.5704424587150616 0.5663446581423447 0.0226689148414055 T T T
0.6107000249276175 0.6135291098387239 0.0300292388433967 T T T
0.5669046422873255 0.7003281938903977 0.0319144657440145 T T T
0.6977285234698456 0.5710961793630637 0.0294387553999455 T T T
0.6102322222436578 0.7445457116402555 0.0317026817790197 T T T
0.5687411228864871 0.8385637774676993 0.0269130632376131 T T T
0.6974560775899811 0.7008231229686606 0.0307299760947297 T T T
0.7407725152571834 0.6144350744311355 0.0299829586781568 T T T
0.8349590514158605 0.5701766233657143 0.0238469615110206 T T T
0.5690691261216742 0.0232706014607518 0.5707034817022043 T T T
0.6132455197534110 0.0294218327746241 0.6145676249227153 T T T
0.5696957890155152 0.0298197346438362 0.7011400498102468 T T T
0.6128487952254718 0.0290289022729068 0.7454145799250146 T T T
0.7001752251260775 0.0288475860019731 0.5710557719501045 T T T
0.5654550314646565 0.0232782556492474 0.8397593727121317 T T T
0.7444476294236664 0.0285370093089614 0.6138265838712237 T T T
0.7003450676522520 0.0286669956211352 0.7012457070357556 T T T
0.8388989373247273 0.0221618931560139 0.5663691331969118 T T T
0.1622163842522782 0.9756531876827486 0.4278442276399677 T T T
0.2565563154124961 0.9695251091853125 0.3870602761827414 T T T
0.3004097972643590 0.9705874608622913 0.2999124717651044 T T T
0.4311467058464787 0.9773807861466337 0.1626328814962017 T T T
0.3006450881062386 0.9689408132411280 0.4308274183784889 T T T
0.3870993663713686 0.9707381401130746 0.2569769444590434 T T T
0.4305662530439303 0.9701955208053852 0.3005857779106677 T T T
0.3877036764432140 0.9697837475621301 0.3876664828293550 T T T
0.4347570757641749 0.9757580706924323 0.4290711234682729 T T T
0.1589013926990945 0.4347229361570106 0.9768472314185984 T T T
0.2536288207471321 0.3875914091208595 0.9696943037652010 T T T
0.2985207535859735 0.3006871832268335 0.9681204228539392 T T T
0.2975939476973446 0.4304088786843907 0.9697706607768244 T T T
0.4333683641839866 0.1622713896243650 0.9745585115813518 T T T
0.3857431969541562 0.2565905876086940 0.9686145566139374 T T T
0.4283176299030663 0.3007208859902952 0.9688735183172613 T T T
0.3846170727130697 0.3873597969859182 0.9689172905136517 T T T
0.4288064302343300 0.4320504471537673 0.9738699030230715 T T T
0.9687541883684809 0.3000154130046259 0.2999634094134248 T T T
0.9716252690221433 0.4363270831798626 0.1628616809055520 T T T
0.9747944915781781 0.1610963236738497 0.4345761784937485 T T T
0.9675359679808226 0.3877764168596466 0.2566129089061943 T T T
0.9689345875239441 0.2554923894780764 0.3873273066072590 T T T
0.9677026700356592 0.4301571506368507 0.3010018073815382 T T T
0.9689731850178710 0.2992600687017351 0.4304308959964563 T T T
0.9690214596627157 0.3860361357558801 0.3872087730337914 T T T
0.9763574187244417 0.4297572032073753 0.4307600270791518 T T T
0.5699797385950707 0.6992134188601870 0.6979759687597690 T T T
0.5692399296917015 0.5680155398389437 0.8349010857023158 T T T
0.5660407508877472 0.8382109542751981 0.5710977974284699 T T T
0.6134637436811465 0.6124516680413126 0.7408943896197402 T T T
0.6132526595459008 0.7437806624018281 0.6116290033840182 T T T
0.7007964769662830 0.7000662719597421 0.5683934251286075 T T T
0.7004972157037964 0.5693969295398345 0.6978118887645884 T T T
0.7450234759971872 0.6126097599875676 0.6113565842041800 T T T
0.8395911862256692 0.5653958751250332 0.5706350741170336 T T T
0.0276600726137025 0.7472208554582975 0.7463380916687482 T T T
0.5247406330190387 0.2540058885325480 0.2532943358968928 T T T
0.4741669657729822 0.7462150468837000 0.0327589194569062 T T T
0.7471027976625557 0.0261334549793207 0.7485963874966202 T T T
0.2545505424215165 0.9680212062263306 0.5236102284785358 T T T
0.9721979962926756 0.2531433683004055 0.2521540439623274 T T T
0.7480109715761756 0.7478479882981637 0.4773149800128820 T T T
0.2531824722757034 0.2545345329517040 0.9667240877101591 T T T
0.0264119074522771 0.6117108632556785 0.4889716125283541 T T T
0.0202977698980699 0.4906968064274217 0.6150258600898931 T T T
0.0132377595699680 0.8726786082021999 0.4902934023603134 T T T
0.0251718440403447 0.4857488732272404 0.8709370126676179 T T T
0.0340844297515667 0.8735580605922225 0.6013506914448769 T T T
0.0135262823848723 0.6105066505118817 0.8786759555231586 T T T
0.9536013054901714 0.7917240910869022 0.7829252589590054 T T T
0.0993932167855757 0.7375570524067203 0.7443382769692786 T T T
0.1280961179348254 0.3856043922356401 0.5078906663530185 T T T
0.1283314346772920 0.5080505270490205 0.3829711374037283 T T T
0.3807438284572169 0.5119969242147773 0.1264269285319793 T T T
0.3795955722046745 0.1243726294049130 0.5070215836303367 T T T
0.5059494544228960 0.3909693123889380 0.1208511479647651 T T T
0.5124290935130800 0.1268957679410119 0.3970792942110131 T T T
0.5822818902608078 0.2655888324152492 0.2575681651429148 T T T
0.5355919582145668 0.2088844464497902 0.2151061044502367 T T T
0.4927673835800621 0.6096265895009644 0.0180971207267199 T T T
0.6179454323542188 0.4886071683177725 0.0191043781244153 T T T
0.4867118255791860 0.8735051071667725 0.0365269021401143 T T T
0.6195453856101558 0.8756493779133490 0.0116356652328914 T T T
0.8725419133995033 0.4962068138406518 0.0107526799757304 T T T
0.8693508098641677 0.6108273292516090 0.0300961666054597 T T T
0.4167405284816941 0.7345232993835062 0.1062763316417818 T T T
0.4630373099092234 0.7912938284028104 0.9604399692308236 T T T
0.4871338168783322 0.0318421978793000 0.6110420959611774 T T T
0.6183223279735872 0.0075388891956658 0.4979795409028779 T T T
0.4938300871568695 0.0060580027887788 0.8771061178536824 T T T
0.6017160607539214 0.0343865847722593 0.8747473431803767 T T T
0.8712449453363360 0.0259698541777330 0.4861460000670701 T T T
0.8789342235268216 0.0110165484979829 0.6124032144965708 T T T
0.7825236917344318 0.9525565233031974 0.7945688421781760 T T T
0.7456500399245993 0.0981512043020172 0.7377004997134674 T T T
0.1308557435233137 0.9667154363468673 0.3865145917400608 T T T
0.1212167896552429 0.9922864845876184 0.5000519424299149 T T T
0.3819126514225625 0.9932443205478224 0.1233539408445861 T T T
0.5130774075933016 0.9687357166323131 0.1297385484927316 T T T
0.3984446294888719 0.9645959917236533 0.5114464523737411 T T T
0.5061324561139913 0.9934867509156174 0.3775721816459950 T T T
0.1190512369078054 0.3897535403692099 0.9858214289369904 T T T
0.1261591239953944 0.5140862974391538 0.9759048806354182 T T T
0.3976144140723614 0.1271965660840621 0.9629268608473056 T T T
0.5043249313754875 0.1250524274324135 0.9928992387774517 T T T
0.3815907350534134 0.5089570545411101 0.9804882531914327 T T T
0.5084264533052523 0.3887030285280743 0.9731692722385120 T T T
0.9644683900898213 0.3985541591709347 0.1264207950223285 T T T
0.9882522192160714 0.1202548641245594 0.3881816769975774 T T T
0.9838367529206068 0.5104304975431357 0.1274188408973625 T T T
0.9683612981052371 0.1295552445455221 0.5156112514281124 T T T
0.9808341733394270 0.5075851405290215 0.3850093018322613 T T T
0.9799021079833354 0.3841309459782932 0.5088339152011248 T T T
0.4898404459989499 0.6116378103380076 0.8705419368101214 T T T
0.4948689069170510 0.8752915549578417 0.6230577843428566 T T T
0.6164968699576272 0.4911824464104594 0.8712672644245005 T T T
0.6024099944300378 0.8732503929543490 0.4887851756622008 T T T
0.8788575245027097 0.6088756059448722 0.4932515361078514 T T T
0.8727765416262988 0.4870307767296108 0.6175803831888662 T T T
0.0463018513887616 0.2173804945261090 0.2070360158397929 T T T
0.7850730030460199 0.7916357666033514 0.4709015279019327 T T T
0.2570574679807853 0.2677203717050666 0.8928321432827793 T T T
0.2572358995217792 0.8945375650496826 0.5807575538440394 T T T
0.2182840750993724 0.0399990421014366 0.5351114891643741 T T T
0.7458564205849308 0.7393340173250682 0.4166662082289213 T T T
0.2164550584695072 0.2076891687241083 0.0384636913044805 T T T
0.9006380347001319 0.2544653370327630 0.2620740212010935 T T T
0.4314368363956531 0.9997889009357193 0.5707614839429125 T T T
0.4296773359767223 0.5681566383150276 0.9980771348826756 T T T
0.0032782707338975 0.5661380330263268 0.4308188163047912 T T T
0.4314141680114737 0.0003541614762466 0.0004877694303379 T T T
0.0008759054007812 0.9972975252663382 0.4293990655374074 T T T
0.9958610034229408 0.4343176637857518 0.9993795752510620 T T T
0.5682028715408406 0.0000889960317890 0.4325640171039207 T T T
0.5687441899690014 0.4325016689756594 0.9963010249533223 T T T
0.0009103163049948 0.4299707219072807 0.5687054732325382 T T T
0.5681524635029344 0.0004361116244331 0.0018732431360659 T T T
0.0003017602909264 0.0008320452448580 0.5657829623101353 T T T
0.9974066110771946 0.5697036247663809 0.0024294224745891 T T T
[ Edited ]